QUESTION:
An applicant’s background check revealed a recent misdemeanor arrest that the applicant failed to disclose on their application. Are we allowed to ask the applicant questions about the arrest even though the background check indicated that the case has not yet been resolved?

OUR ANSWER FROM HORTYSPRINGER ATTORNEY HALA MOUZAFFAR:
Absolutely!

It is the hospital’s responsibility, through the credentialing and privileging process, to appoint only highly qualified providers.  To do so, the burden should be on the applicant to demonstrate current clinical competence and an ability to practice safely.  Therefore, it is important to keep the burden on the applicant to resolve any doubts related to their qualifications.  This includes answering additional questions and resolving any doubts that may come up in the course of reviewing their application.  An application that has red flags or outstanding questions should not be processed further until the underlying issues are resolved to the satisfaction of the hospital.

An arrest, for instance, is something that would certainly require follow-up.  Specifically, when was the arrest? Why was the applicant arrested? Were any charges brought against the applicant? Why did the applicant leave this information out of their application? These are questions for the applicant to resolve prior to the hospital processing the application further.

It does not matter if the applicant’s criminal case has not yet been resolved.  The hospital has the ability to ask those questions it feels need to be answered, and for documentation to support those answers, in order to properly resolve any questions about the applicant, and in this case their arrest.