U.S. ex rel. Sheldon v. Kettering Health Network (Summary)

FALSE CLAIMS ACT

U.S. ex rel. Sheldon v. Kettering Health Network, No. 1:14-cv-345 (S.D. Ohio Jan. 6, 2015)

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio dismissed a relator’s False Claims Act (“FCA”) claim against a hospital, holding that the relator failed to allege that the hospital submitted any false claim to the government. The relator alleged that her estranged husband began an extramarital relationship while being an employee of defendant, a hospital. In furtherance of this relationship, the relator alleged that her estranged husband accessed and shared her protected electronic health care information with others. The relator sued the hospital for violating the FCA. The relator claimed that the hospital failed to adhere to the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act (“HITECH Act”) and falsely certified its compliance with the HITECH Act, thereby collecting undeserved “Meaningful Use” dollars from the federal government.

The court dismissed the relator’s suit, holding that the relator failed to allege that the hospital was not compliant with the HITECH Act or submitted any false claims or certifications to the government for payment. The relator incorrectly argued that an isolated privacy breach constituted a violation of the HITECH Act. However, the court found that the hospital was compliant with the HITECH requirements and followed its instructions after it discovered the relator’s breach. Furthermore, the relator did not have adequate personal knowledge of any false claims or certification by the hospital. The relator was never an employee of the hospital or involved in any claim or certification. Instead, she based her whole argument on secondhand knowledge from her estranged husband.